Purchase-to-Pay Benchmarking

Measure Purchase-to-Pay Performance, Quantify AI Opportunity and Accelerate Procurement Value

Most organizations benchmark purchase-to-pay performance to improve transactional efficiency. AI World Class benchmarking goes further by quantifying what becomes possible when sourcing, purchasing, and payment processes are redesigned around artificial intelligence (AI) to improve procurement productivity, supplier performance and business value.

The Hackett Group® helps procurement leaders benchmark purchase-to-pay performance against peer organizations, Digital World Class® performers and AI World Class standards to identify performance gaps, quantify AI opportunities, and prioritize investments that increase procurement productivity, improve supplier performance and accelerate business value.

The purchase-to-pay performance gap is growing

Purchase-to-pay sits at the intersection of spending, supplier performance and enterprise value. Yet many organizations continue to manage purchasing, invoice processing and payment as disconnected activities. AI World Class organizations are redesigning the entire process, creating measurable advantages in procurement productivity, savings generation, supplier performance and business value.

Cost and productivity pressure

Procurement leaders face growing pressure to reduce operating costs while managing increasing spend with leaner teams.

Supplier performance expectations

Organizations expect procurement to strengthen supplier performance, resilience and commercial outcomes while reducing risk.

Maverick spend and process inefficiency

Disconnected purchasing processes, manual work, and low buying compliance continue to erode savings and productivity.

AI investment decisions

Leaders need objective insight into where AI can create the greatest procurement and enterprise value.

What we benchmark across purchase-to-pay

End-to-end purchase-to-pay performance

The Hackett Group® benchmarks the complete purchase-to-pay process, providing an objective view of performance across every stage of purchasing, invoice processing and payment.

Procurement data management

Supplier, item, catalog and contract data management

Intake management and requisition processing

Requisition creation and approval, requisition processing, and intake management

Purchase order processing

Purchase order creation, approval, release and change order processing

Supplier scheduling

Supplier requirements review and inbound tactical supply management

Receipt processing

Delivery assurance, receipt processing, inquiry support and dispute resolution

Accounts payable

Invoice-to-purchase-order matching and payment processing

Quantify your order-to-cash performance gap

Order-to-cash benchmarking provides an objective view of where performance gaps exist today, where AI can create the greatest value and what future-state performance is achievable.

Benchmark against today’s leaders and tomorrow’s possibilities

Digital World Class® benchmarks measure how leading purchase-to-pay organizations perform today. AI World Class benchmarks quantify the future-state performance achievable when purchase-to-pay processes are redesigned around AI-enabled execution.

Decision-grade procurement benchmarks for high-stakes decisions

As AI adoption accelerates across sourcing and procurement, leaders need more than generic recommendations. Strategic investment decisions require validated benchmark data, procurement analytics, peer comparability and quantified business outcomes.

The AI World Class purchase-to-pay performance gap 1

Process reinvention unlocks the full value of AI. AI transformation is not technology-led. It is process-led. AI World Class organizations redesign purchase-to-pay from purchasing through payment, creating compounding improvements in procurement productivity, buying compliance, invoice quality and business value.

110%
Greater guided buying
Increase policy compliance and help employees make better purchasing decisions from the start.
69%
Less maverick spend
Reduce off-contract purchasing while increasing spend under management and negotiated savings.
74%
Faster invoice processing
Accelerate invoice processing through greater automation and fewer manual interventions.
76%
Fewer invoice errors
Improve invoice accuracy while reducing exceptions, rework and downstream processing effort.
80%
Lower process costs
Redesign work to dramatically reduce transaction costs across the purchase-to-pay process.
81%
Lower staffing requirements
Enable procurement and accounts payable teams to manage significantly more work with the same or fewer resources.

1 AI World Class benchmark modeling based on peer median and AI World Class performance scenarios, The Hackett Group®, 2026

How we help procurement leaders prioritize AI investments

Using Digital World Class® and AI World Class benchmarks, procurement leaders can identify performance gaps, evaluate AI opportunities and build a transformation roadmap grounded in measurable business outcomes.

Trusted by the world’s best companies

The Hackett Group® provides benchmark standards used by many of the world’s highest-performing organizations, including 97% of the Dow Jones Industrial Average, 90% of the Fortune 100, 68% of the DAX 40 and 53% of the FTSE 100. Our Digital World Class® and AI World Class benchmarks help procurement leaders identify performance gaps, quantify AI opportunities, and prioritize investments with confidence.

The AI Procurement Performance Gap

The AI Procurement Performance Gap

AI World Class research shows leading procurement organizations are redesigning procurement around artificial intelligence (AI)…

Purchase-to-Pay Software Market Intelligence Research – Key Findings

Purchase-to-Pay Software Market Intelligence Research – Key Findings

Season 4, Episode 36

In this episode of the Business Excelleration™ Podcast, which Purchase-to-Pay software solutions provide the greatest…

Purchase-to-Pay Software Solution Provider Perspective - Summary Report

Digital World Class® Matrix: P2P Solution Provider Perspective – Summary Report

A newly released Digital World Class® Matrix report analyzes and ranks 10 leading purchase-to-pay (P2P)…

3M – Digital Transformation in Purchase-to-Pay

3M – Digital Transformation in Purchase-to-Pay

Season 4, Episode 30

In 2022, 3M won a Digital Award from The Hackett Group for their digital transformation…

Frequently asked questions

What is purchase-to-pay benchmarking?

Purchase-to-pay benchmarking compares the cost, productivity, quality and business outcomes of your purchase-to-pay process against peer organizations, Digital World Class® performers and AI World Class benchmarks. It helps procurement leaders identify performance gaps, quantify AI opportunities, and prioritize investments that reduce costs, increase productivity and strengthen business value.

How does purchase-to-pay benchmarking improve procurement performance?

Purchase-to-pay benchmarking identifies performance gaps, quantifies AI opportunities, and helps procurement leaders prioritize the initiatives with the greatest potential to improve productivity, reduce costs and strengthen supplier relationships.

What is the difference between Digital World Class® and AI World Class purchase-to-pay benchmarks?

Digital World Class® benchmarks measure current purchase-to-pay performance based on leading operating models, technology and best practices. AI World Class benchmarks quantify future-state performance achievable when purchase-to-pay processes are redesigned around AI-enabled execution and process-led AI transformation.

How does purchase-to-pay benchmarking help build a business case for AI investments?

Purchase-to-pay benchmarking identifies performance gaps at the process, subprocess and work-step level, helping organizations quantify expected productivity improvements, cost reductions and ROI before investing in AI transformation.

Which purchase-to-pay processes should be benchmarked first?

Most organizations begin by benchmarking procurement data management, requisition processing, purchase order processing, supplier scheduling, receipt processing and accounts payable. The right starting point depends on where performance gaps and AI opportunities are the greatest.

How can purchase-to-pay benchmarking improve invoice processing?

Benchmarking identifies opportunities to reduce invoice errors, automate invoice matching, accelerate processing and eliminate manual work. AI World Class organizations redesign invoice processing to improve productivity while reducing transaction costs.

What is accounts payable benchmarking?

Accounts payable benchmarking evaluates invoice processing, invoice-to-purchase-order matching, payment processing and accounts payable productivity. It helps organizations improve efficiency, reduce processing costs, strengthen financial controls and increase purchase-to-pay performance.

What is the purchase-to-pay process?

The purchase-to-pay process connects purchasing, receiving, invoice processing and payment. It spans the full procurement transaction lifecycle and provides the foundation for measuring spend, compliance, productivity, and process performance.

What is the difference between purchase-to-pay and procure-to-pay?

Purchase-to-pay and procure-to-pay are often used interchangeably. Purchase-to-pay typically focuses on purchasing through payment, while procure-to-pay can be used more broadly to describe requisitioning, purchase orders, receipt, invoice matching and payment.

What are AI World Class purchase-to-pay benchmarks?

AI World Class purchase-to-pay benchmarks quantify the performance organizations can achieve when purchasing, invoice processing and payment workflows are redesigned around AI. They measure future-state improvements in procurement productivity, process costs, cycle time and business value.

What is purchase-to-pay AI?

Purchase-to-pay AI applies artificial intelligence across purchasing, invoice processing and payment workflows to improve automation, increase productivity, reduce manual effort, and strengthen purchase-to-pay performance.

How do I measure my purchase-to-pay AI opportunity?

Benchmark current purchase-to-pay performance against AI World Class standards to identify performance gaps, quantify AI opportunities, and prioritize the investments with the greatest potential to improve procurement productivity, reduce costs and accelerate business value.

What is procure-to-pay benchmarking?

Procure-to-pay benchmarking compares procure-to-pay process performance against peers and leading organizations to identify cost, productivity, quality and automation gaps. It helps leaders improve process efficiency, strengthen supplier performance and prioritize AI transformation opportunities.

What are procurement benchmarks?

Procurement benchmarks compare procurement cost, productivity, compliance, supplier performance, and business value against peers and leading organizations. They help procurement leaders identify performance gaps, prioritize AI transformation opportunities and improve purchase-to-pay performance.

Benchmark purchase-to-pay performance.
Prioritize AI investment. Accelerate ROI.